The Long Term Cost of Short Term Relief
By Trent Carter
Instagram | Facebook | LinkedIn | TikTok
Pain is uncomfortable. That’s kind of the point.
And I don't mean that to sound harsh. I mean it literally. Pain is the body's way of saying something is wrong. It's information. A signal. The problem is that we've built an entire medical system around making that signal disappear as fast as possible, and somewhere along the way we stopped asking whether that was actually the right goal.
I get it. Nobody wants to watch a patient suffer. That's not why any of us got into this work. There's nothing noble about letting someone sit in pain when you have something in your hand that can fix it. I've felt that pull a thousand times. The chart is in front of you, the patient is hurting, and you have fifteen minutes before the next one walks through the door.
The easy thing and the right thing aren't always the same thing. That's not a comfortable sentence to sit with when you're the one holding the prescription pad.
But here's what I've seen after years of treating addiction in rural New Mexico: the faster we reach for something to make discomfort disappear, the more we set people up for a much harder road down the line. Not always. Not with every patient. But often enough that I can't ignore it anymore. Often enough that it changed how I practice.
Click here for my free Short Term Relief worksheet
The Biology Nobody Explained
Opioids are the obvious example. A patient comes in with back pain. Real pain. Legitimate pain. We prescribe something for it. It works. Really well, actually. Too well, sometimes.
The pain goes away. But so does everything else.
Anxiety. Loneliness. The low-grade sadness that was already there before the injury. The thing they've been quietly white-knuckling through for years before they ever set foot in my office. The pill handles all of it at once, and the brain notices.
That's not weakness. That's biology.
The brain has a reward system. It's ancient, and it's very good at its job. When something reliably makes you feel better, the brain files that away. It starts to expect it. Crave it. Over time, it starts to need it just to feel normal, because normal is now defined as having the substance present.
This is not a character flaw. I want to be really clear about that, because I've watched too many patients carry shame about something their nervous system was doing without their permission. You didn't decide to get addicted. Your brain decided that this thing was essential for survival, because at some point, it kind of was.
What I tell patients now is this: we were never just treating your back. We were treating everything you were carrying. And when the prescription ran out, all of that was still there. The back might have healed. Everything else didn't.
Short-term relief has a price tag. It just doesn't show up on the bill right away.
It's Not Only About Opioids
I think about this pattern constantly. Not just with opioids. Benzos. Alcohol. The way some people use food, or work, or screens. Exercise can do it. Gambling. Even relationships, honestly. Anything that reliably makes you feel better fast can become the thing you reach for every time things get hard.
Not because you're broken. Because your brain is doing exactly what it's designed to do.
Find relief. Repeat what works.
The trouble is that most of these things stop working over time. The dose that used to help starts to feel like nothing. So you go a little higher. The behavior you used to do on weekends starts creeping into the week. The thing that used to take the edge off now just gets you to baseline. And baseline keeps dropping.
That is the hidden cost. That is what I mean when I say short-term relief is expensive.
You're not buying a fix. You're taking out a loan. And the interest compounds.
I've had patients who didn't touch opioids until their fifties. Decades of functioning, of holding things together, and then a surgery, a script, and eighteen months later they're in my office trying to figure out how their life came apart. That's not a failure of willpower. That's a brain that found something that worked, and did what brains do.
Understanding that changes everything. It changes how I talk to patients. It changes how I explain what's happening to them. And more than anything, it changes what we do about it.
The Question We Never Ask Soon Enough
The real question we never ask early enough is: works for how long?
We're good at asking "will this help?" We ask that question constantly. Will this medication reduce pain? Will this intervention improve outcomes? Will this make my patient more comfortable? Those are all reasonable questions. They're just incomplete.
The follow-up question is: and then what?
In primary care, we're often so focused on the immediate problem that we're not thinking three moves ahead. The patient in front of us has pain. We treat the pain. Visit over. But addiction doesn't announce itself upfront. It builds quietly, in the background, while we're looking at something else. By the time it becomes visible, the roots are already deep.
I'm not saying we need to treat every patient like a potential addict. That's not it. But I do think we need to be more honest about risk. More willing to have the awkward conversation before it becomes necessary, rather than after.
Because here's the thing I've learned: people can handle honest information. What they struggle with is discovering later that they weren't given it.
I can't count how many patients have sat across from me and said some version of "nobody told me this could happen." Nobody told them that this medication, the one they took exactly as prescribed, could rewire the way their brain processes reward and relief. Nobody explained that stopping it cold would feel like the worst flu of their life. Nobody mentioned that the anxiety they'd feel when they tried to quit wasn't new anxiety, it was all the old anxiety coming back at once, unfiltered.
That's on us. Not on them.
What Honest Care Actually Looks Like
In my clinic, I think about this differently now than I used to. When someone comes in hurting, the answer isn't always "here's something to stop the hurt." Sometimes the answer is "let's figure out what's driving it." That conversation takes longer. It's harder. It doesn't always fit neatly into a fifteen-minute appointment slot.
But it's the only approach that actually works.
I ask different questions than I used to. Not just "where does it hurt" but "how long has it hurt, what have you tried, what's been going on in your life, what does a normal day look like for you?" Those questions tell me a lot more than imaging and vitals. They tell me what I'm actually dealing with.
A lot of the patients I see in addiction treatment weren't recreational drug users. They were people in pain, physical or otherwise, who found something that worked and couldn't stop when it stopped working. They were doing the only thing that made sense given what they knew and what they had access to. My job is to give them something better. Not just something else to take, but a real alternative to the cycle they're stuck in.
That means treating the whole person. I know that sounds like a bumper sticker. But I mean it practically. If someone is self-medicating anxiety, we address the anxiety. If someone is using alcohol to sleep, we address the sleep. If someone is using opioids to manage pain from a condition that was never properly treated, we go back and treat the condition. Properly this time.
You can't just take away the thing that's working, even if it's destroying them, without giving them something to replace it. That's not treatment. That's just removal. And removal without support almost always ends the same way.
Why Rural Communities Get Hit Harder
I practice in rural New Mexico. That context matters.
Out here, the options are fewer. There's no psychiatrist down the street. There's no outpatient rehab center with flexible hours and sliding scale fees. There's no robust public transit system to get someone to and from appointments three times a week. There's a lot of distance, a lot of pride, and a lot of people who waited a long time before asking for help because they didn't have anywhere to go.
The short-term relief problem hits harder in places like this. Not because rural people are more vulnerable, but because the infrastructure to catch the long-term cost simply isn't there. When someone in a metro area develops a dependence problem, they have options. Crisis lines, ERs with social workers, specialists. It's not perfect, but it exists.
Out here, I'm often what exists. That's not a complaint. It's just the reality, and it shapes how I think about every prescription I write.
When I prescribe something with dependence potential in a rural community, I'm making a decision with fewer safety nets around it. That sharpens your thinking pretty quickly. It makes you slower to reach for certain solutions. It makes you more invested in the conversation that happens before the prescription rather than the one that happens after.
I also think there's a cultural piece in rural communities around stoicism and self-reliance. People don't want to be seen as struggling. They've managed everything else themselves. Asking for help with substance use feels like a different category of weakness than asking for help with a broken leg, even though it shouldn't. That means people often come in later, when things are further along, and that changes what treatment looks like.
Medication Is a Bridge, Not a Destination
I want to be clear about something before this starts to sound like an argument against medication, because it isn't.
Buprenorphine has saved lives in this community. Real people I know by name. People who have children, and jobs, and people who love them. People who are alive right now because we had an effective medication option and I was willing to prescribe it. I don't take that lightly.
Medication is part of treatment. Full stop.
But there's a difference between using medication as part of a real plan and using it as a substitute for one. Buprenorphine prescribed thoughtfully, with counseling and monitoring and a real long-term strategy, is a lifeline. Buprenorphine handed out without any support structure or follow-through is just replacing one dependency with another, even if the new one is safer and more stable.
The goal was never to be on medication forever. The goal is a life that functions. A life where the person is present for the people who need them, where they can work and sleep and feel things without everything being filtered through a substance. Medication helps get there. It's not the destination.
I tell patients that up front. I want them to understand what we're building toward, not just what we're doing today. Because when people understand the plan, they engage with it differently. They're not just compliant. They're invested. And that investment is what actually drives long-term recovery.
The Conversation Nobody Wants to Have First
Here's the hardest part of all this. Prevention requires honesty at a moment when honesty is inconvenient.
A patient comes in after surgery, or with a new pain diagnosis, or just worn down after a hard year, and they're hoping you're going to make them feel better. That's a vulnerable moment. They're not there to hear a warning. They're there for relief.
And I have to decide, in real time, whether to have the harder conversation or the easier one.
The easier one is faster. It resolves the immediate problem. The patient leaves satisfied. My numbers look fine.
The harder one plants a seed. It takes an extra ten minutes. It might make the patient uncomfortable. It might make them feel like I'm not fully on their side. But it gives them something they can't get anywhere else, which is accurate information about what's coming if we're not careful.
I've learned to have the harder conversation. Not every time, not with every patient, but when the risk is real, I say it plainly. I tell them what the medication does, what the risks are, what to watch for. I tell them we're going to check in and that I want to know if something feels off. I tell them this isn't a judgment, it's just what good care looks like.
Most patients appreciate it. A few are annoyed. I can live with annoyed. What I can't live with is finding out six months later that someone I saw had a preventable problem because I took the easy way out.
The Actual Long-Term Cost
So what is the long-term cost of short-term relief, really?
It's measured in relapses and relationships. In jobs lost and kids who grew up with a parent who wasn't fully present. In people who spent years trying to figure out what was wrong with them, when nothing was wrong with them, they were just stuck in a cycle that nobody helped them see clearly.
It's measured in clinic visits that keep treating symptoms while the underlying problem compounds. In emergency rooms that become primary care for people who fell through every other crack. In communities that lose people who should still be here.
Those are the hidden costs. They don't show up on the original bill. But they're real, and they're enormous, and most of them were preventable.
I don't believe in blame when it comes to addiction. Not for patients, and not for the clinicians who were doing the best they could with what they knew. But I do believe in doing better. And doing better means slowing down long enough to ask the harder questions before things get hard.
The short-term fix feels like medicine. Sometimes it is. But real treatment looks further down the road than the next appointment. It asks not just what will help today, but what does this person's life look like in a year, in five years, and what are we doing right now that shapes that?
That's the work. It's slower. It's less satisfying in the moment. And it's the only thing I've found that actually makes a difference.
-Trent
About Trent Carter
Trent Carter is a clinician, entrepreneur, and addiction recovery advocate dedicated to transforming lives through evidence-based care, innovation, and leadership. He is the founder of Renew Health and the author of The Recovery Tool Belt.
Build Your Recovery Toolkit
Want a deeper dive into proven strategies for lasting recovery?
Grab your copy of The Recovery Tool Belt — an actionable guide packed with real-world tools, patient stories, and step-by-step support.
Ready to Take the Next Step?
Connect with Trent’s team at Renew Health for personalized, evidence-based addiction recovery care: